Freehold FAQ's
Why was the Law enacted?
The Law was enacted for a number of reasons, namely:
1. To regulate and supplement the existing practice in
relation to property registration for UAE Nationals;
2. To clarify and confirm the actual status of GCC Nationals
in regards to their rights to own Dubai property;
3. To nominate development projects that can be owned as
freehold by foreigners;
4. To provide a regime whereby individuals can be provided
with a confirmation of their rights to purchase and own
a property in Dubai, as well as the security of having title
to the property registered to them.
What is the status of UAE and GCC Nationals under
the Law?
No distinction is made between UAE and GCC Nationals, as
they are afforded equal status under the provisions of the
Law.
UAE and GCC Nationals can own any property right throughout
Dubai and have the title registered in their name at the
Land Department. The property right that they may own includes
freehold ownership, a long lease of up to 99 years, the
right to build on the land owned by another person, known
as the right of Musataha (which we commonly see in Ground
Development Leases), and a usufruct right (the right to
use and exploit property belonging to another person).
What is the position of ownership for nationalities
other than UAE or GCC Nationals?
Article 4 of the new Law provides that all nationalities
other than UAE or GCC nationals can own freehold title,
a 99 year lease, or a usufruct right in designated areas
of Dubai, as determined by the Ruler’s approval. We
are currently awaiting the first of such Ruler’s approvals
but the current indications are that this will be issued
shortly and that it will include the expected projects within
the portfolios of Dubai Properties, Nakheel and Emaar. Some
other projects may also be included, for example, those
located at Dubailand.
Does the Law distinguish between foreign individuals
and companies?
The right to own property in the Ruler’s designated
areas and obtain a registered title extends to both foreign
individuals and foreign companies. However, any company
that wishes to purchase property in the designated areas
must be able to prove its lawful existence in its home country.
What is the status of long leases in areas other
than those designated by the Ruler?
Long leases in areas other than those designated by the
Ruler are not registerable at the Land Department by foreigners
under the new Law. These leases remain as personal rights
and are not illegal in any way. Unregistered long leases
in areas outside of those areas designated by the Ruler
remain enforceable as personal contractual rights between
the parties. It must be noted that any dispute arising from
an unregistered long lease will still be adjudicated by
the Rent Committee.
Is there any way for a foreigner to own property
in non-designated areas?
Article 26 of the new Law deals with the circumstances
where agreements are made that purport to give a property
ownership right to someone who is not entitled to own it,
and who is therefore not entitled to register it under the
new Law.
Article 26(1) states that any agreement or sale made in
violation of the provisions of the Law (or with the intent
to circumvent its provisions) shall be null and void. Article
26(2) goes further to say that any interested third party;
the Land Department or the public prosecution has the right
to request the court to declare such a transaction void.
There is no way under the new Law for a foreign person to
own property in any non-designated areas. If a foreign person
wishes to “own” property in the non-designated
areas, he should enter into a long lease for the property,
which, although will not be possible to register, will not
go against the provisions of the new Law.
Why is registration of title so important?
Registration of a person’s interest on the title
of a property provides conclusive evidence of his ownership.
Article 22 of the new Law provides that the Land Department
shall issue a title deed of real property rights in accordance
with the current records in the Real Property Registers.
Article 24 goes further to say that the title deed referred
to under Article 22 shall have absolute power of evidence
to establish real property rights.
What is the process for title registration?
Article 6 of the new Law states that the Land Department
shall solely, to the exclusion of others, be authorised
to register real property rights and long term leases as
provided under Article 4. Once a property is completed and
handed over to the purchaser, the purchaser can then procure
the developer to register the title to the property in the
name of the purchaser in the Real Property Register at the
Land Department. The Sale and Purchase Agreement as well
as the accompanying scheme documentation will possibly need
to be translated into Arabic (which should be undertaken
by the developer). The purchaser will then be asked to sign
the Land Department standard transfer form, for the internal
use of the Land Department. This form will provide the details
of the parties, the property, the purchase price, etc.
Will the Land Department charge fees for the registration
of these transfers?
Both the seller and the purchaser will be asked to pay
the Land Department’s fees at the time of title registration.
These currently amount to 2% of the purchase price, which
is broken up by having 1.5% payable by the purchaser and
0.5% payable by the seller. However, it should be noted
that developers commonly require the purchaser to pay the
full 2%. The Land Department’s fees are currently
under review by the Executive Council and may be subject
to change.
Will the Land Department charge the 2% fee on the
original purchase price or the most recent purchase price?
Current practice of the Land Department is that fees are
charged on the original purchase price. However, as the
Land Department introduces new practices, it is envisaged
that the basis on which fees are levied may change, and
they may take into account the purchase price in any on-sale
agreements or the market value of the property.
How would the Land Department know the “market
value” of the property for the purpose of ascertaining
what amount the 2% fee is to be levied on?
Article 6, point 7 of the new Law requires the Land Department
to “lay down the rules in connection with the evaluation
of real properties”. It is envisaged that the Land
Department will employ its own expert valuers. The Land
Department’s valuers will be tasked to verify a property
value; and provide a valuation for a prospective purchaser,
if the prospective purchaser so requests.
What about developers’ internal registries?
Article 6 of the new Law states that the Land Department
shall solely, to the exclusion of others, be authorised
to register the real property rights and long term leases
as provided under Article 4. This means that any register
or other type of database maintained by a developer is not
recognized under this Law. Once we have the Ruler’s
approval of the designated areas, the formal process of
the Land Department registrations can begin. The developer’s
internal registrations will be replaced by the formal registration
in the Land Department in situations where physical hand
over of properties has taken place. However, where a property
is still under construction, developers will no doubt continue
to maintain their own internal registers.
If a third party purchaser has paid a developer
a registration fee, will an additional registration fee
be payable to the Land Department?
Yes. A purchaser will pay two fees. EMAAR, for example,
charges registration fees in additional to the fees payable
to the Land Department. It must be noted that this is only
applicable during this transitional phase, and once the
Land Department registration process is in full swing, no
registration fees should be payable to developers.
How will apartments be registered?
Article 23 of the Law is the only Article dealing with
the registration of individual apartments and offices in
a multi-storey building. The Land Department is currently
working on a new Strata Law which should be issued within
the next few weeks. It is envisaged that this new Strata
Law will fully deal with issues such as ownership and management
of the common areas in the building, Co-Owners Associations,
rules of occupancy and so on.
However, Article 23 sets the tone by stating that a multi
floor or apartment real property shall be considered as
a single real property unit and a folio shall be designated
thereto in the Real Property Register. Supplementary folios
in the names of the owners of such apartments and floors
and common areas shall be added to the original folio. In
practice, the Land Department will open a main register
for the building itself, and within the main register there
will be a sub-register for each apartment or office. The
owner of an apartment or office will be registered as owning
the freehold interest in his unit, together with an undivided
share in the common areas of the building, calculated in
accordance with his participation quota. It is envisaged
that the Constitution of the Co-Owners Association and the
Master Community Declaration (where applicable) will be
registered on the main building register with a notation
of such encumbrances will be shown on the title of each
individual unit.
Will the register at the Land Department be open
to public inspection?
Article 5 of the new Law states that a third party may
inspect the property register and obtain a certified copy
of it, provided that the enquirer has a legitimate reason
for that enquiry. This means that a potential purchaser
of a property, for example, will be able to make his own
enquiries
Who will settle disputes under the new Law?
In relation to the forum for settling disputes under the
new Law, any aggrieved party can file a claim directly with
the Dubai Courts, or implement any arbitration process that
may be agreed between the parties. There is also a possibility
of the Land Department establishing its own arbitration
and conciliation service, but the Land Department has not
yet confirmed this.
It must be noted that, in relation to unregistered long
leases, these fall outside the ambit of the new Law and
the Rents Committee retains jurisdiction of any disputes
arising between landlord and tenants.
What remedies are available under the new Law?
Article 10 of the new Law deals with disputes. In short,
specific performance is not available as a remedy under
the Law, but the available remedy is damages. For example,
if a seller defaults in his obligations under a Sale and
Purchase Agreement and does not transfer the property to
the purchaser, the purchaser can only claim damages from
the seller for the losses suffered and cannot force the
seller to transfer the property to him.
How does the new Law affect the inheritance rules
of property?
Article 11 of the new Law states that any inheritance declaration
that includes real property rights shall be registered in
the real property register. It further states that no dispositions
by any heir in connection with any such rights shall be
valid or effective against third parties, unless such dispositions
are registered. This means that the process will be as follows:-
1. The relatives of the deceased person must apply to
the Court for a declaration that identifies the beneficiaries;
2. The beneficiaries than apply to the Sharia Court to commence
succession proceedings; and
3. The inheritance declaration is registered on the deceased’s
title at the Land Department.
Only when the above process is followed, will the beneficiaries
be recognized as the owners of a property.
But what Law will the Court apply to determine
who the beneficiaries are of a foreign national?
Article 17(5) of the Federal Civil Code states that the
Law of the UAE will be applied to wills made by expatriates
disposing of their real property which is located in the
UAE.
However, a new Federal Law was passed at the end of 2005,
the Personal Affairs Law (No. 28 of 2005). It appears that,
as a result of the new Personal Affairs Law, a foreigner
can opt for the laws of his own country to apply on the
question of inheritance of his property. Although this is
not entirely clear, it is believed that the Land Department
supports this view.
How does a person’s residence status relate
to property ownership and why was this not dealt with in
the new Property Law?
Residency is a Federal Government issue and not a local
property law issue. In principle, a person could own a property
in the UAE and choose not to reside in the property. Despite
the fact that many developers are offering residence visas
to property purchasers, the two issues of ownership of property
and residency/ sponsorship should not be confused.